Author Archives: keithroysdon

Unknown's avatar

About keithroysdon

I'm a lifelong writer of news, pop culture and fiction. Google me - I'm all over the place.

‘Zorro’ and its curious subtitles

I’m enjoying the new “Zorro” series on Amazon Prime Video but it has prompted me to wonder about something: How do networks and streaming services create their subtitles and closed captions and why are they so different, sometimes, from the actual dialogue?

I’ve been watching most TV shows and movies with subtitles – when they’re available – for much of the past year now. Uneven sound mixes prompted me to do that, and while I still consider subtitles kinda distracting, they’re helpful in catching asides (as in series like “Star Trek: Strange New Worlds” with rapid fire, often humorously-phrased dialogue) or series like the wonderful “Derry Girls,” where subtitles are handy to catch all the jokes.

But in keeping an eye on subtitles, I’ve noticed they often vary from the actual dialogue on screen. I’ve wondered if subtitling was done from a script or literally just what the people who write closed-captions can make out. The number of times a caption includes the phrase “unintelligible” makes me think it’s the latter.

And now comes “Zorro,” a Spanish TV production acquired by Prime Video that is obviously dubbed. But here’s the odd thing: The subtitling/captions frequently don’t match the dubbed dialogue.

The dubbed dialogue will be something like “Quickly, we must go outside,” and the subtitle will read something like, “Hurry – we need to catch up!”

So, close in spirit but not in details.

Other than that, the most egregious case of dialogue and captions that don’t match, “Zorro” is good fun so far.

I’ve always been a “Zorro” fan, having caught the original 1957 series starring Guy Williams in reruns. I’ve always loved how the original Johnston McCulley stories – which debuted in 1919 and were adapted into movies ranging from the Douglas Fairbanks silent movie in 1920 to the 1988 film staring Antonio Banderas – clearly influenced the early elements of the Batman comics, including secret lair (often hidden behind a fireplace or bookcase) black horse/Batmobile, preference for dispensing justice in old California with a sword or whip versus a gun, etc.

The new Zorro/Diego de la Vega is played by Miguel Bernardeau, with Renata Notni as Lolita, his headstrong romantic interest and, most intriguingly, Dalia Xiuhcoatl as a Native warrior who trained to succeed the old Zorro, who is ostensibly killed in the series’ opening scenes, along with Diego’s father.

“Zorro” has a cast of familiar characters, played by striking actors, with some interesting twists and additions. I’ll keep watching, with one eye on the subtitles and an ear out for the unmatching dialogue.

‘Is That Black Enough for You?!?’ a groundbreaking documentary about Black cinema

I don’t watch a ton of documentaries on streaming services, particularly those about entertainment and show business. Sometimes it feels like all those have turned into those usually-lame “making of” special features that accompany movies on disc.

That’s why “Is That Black Enough For You?!?” feels like such a revelation. Not only is it revelatory because of its subject matter – there’s a lot to say about Black filmmaking – but it feels like the rare recent entertainment industry documentary that comes from a place of knowledge and passion.

That’s because of Elvis Mitchell, the veteran writer and documentary maker who wrote and directed “Is That Black Enough For You?!?,” which I’m going to refer to, going forward in this blog post, as “Black Enough.” Mitchell is a scholar and deeply invested in the subject.

“Black Enough” – which takes its full title from a wry line from Ossie Davis’ “Cotton Comes to Harlem” from 1970 – is a 2022 Netflix original that escaped my notice until a couple of weeks ago, when I saw a reference to it in an article. (It would be cool if Netflix promoted the film a little more.)

Although the film is marketed as a movie about the period from 1968 to 1978, which included the so-called “blaxploitation” period of action-filled movies, romance films and horror flicks with Black actors and sometimes Black directors that reached audiences of all races, there’s a lot of history from before 1968, when stars like Sidney Poitier and Harry Belafonte – who gives one of his last interviews here – broke through.

We see not only many, many clips but get to enjoy interviews with Belafonte and others including Glynn Turman, Margaret Avery and Samuel L. Jackson

Especially gratifying is the movie’s observations about how Black directors, movie soundtracks and actors influenced so-called “mainstream” cinema: The movie recounts how Black films were copied in other, later films. And when I say “gratifying,” I note that it is not gratifying that so many good-to-great films with Black casts and Black moviemakers like Davis and Gordon Parks and Melvin Van Peebles and Pam Grier and Richard Roundtree and so many others were exploited by other films that stole their groundbreaking moves. But it is gratifying that this history is recognized.

Happily, “Black Enough” was nominated for an Emmy in the documentary film category, and although it didn’t win, the nomination might carry with it increased demand for viewing on Netflix. It’s well worth your 2.5 hours.

‘Leave the World Behind’ – it’s the end of the world as we know it

I generally like “end of the world” thrillers. I don’t even mind those with endings that leave me hanging. That’s probably why I liked “Leave the World Behind.”

About a year ago, I wrote a piece for Gutter Review, “Apocalypse Then: The Superiority of Bygone Disaster Films,” about how in general I thought classic end-of-the-world films like “Invasion of the Body Snatchers” and “The World, the Flesh and the Devil” were better treatment of the kind of apocalyptic stories that were the currency of science fiction literature of the first 60 years of the 20th century than their modern counterparts.

So I went into “Leave the World Behind,” director Sam Esmail’s thriller for Netflix, kind of cautiously. What happens if I hated the film, which grew out of a production pact with Barack and Michelle Obama and starred a great cast, including Mahershala Ali, Julia Roberts and Ethan Hawke? I’d hate to hate it.

No worries. The film, while long on set-up and short on “Panic in the Year Zero”-style payoff, is satisfying.

Actually, there’s a very contained version of “Panic” – released in 1962 and starring Ray Milland as a hard-nosed survivor leading his family group through the hours and days after nuclear war – in “Leave,” with the same kind of “I’m sure they’ll figure it out soon” vibe.

Added to that end-of-the-world flavor is a treatment of race and class. Roberts and Hawke play a New York City couple who, along with their kids, go for a weekend in the country to a luxurious house. They’ve barely settled in when the Internet goes out and the owner of the house (Ali) and his daughter show up. They’re unable to get to the city and need to stay over at their AirB&B. Roberts’ character is uptight and – much is made of this – hates people. Roberts’ reluctance to let the visitors move back into their own house is noted by Ali’s daughter, played by Myha’la.

Once accommodations are figured out, the next order of business is to connect with the outside world. There’s not as much “Panic”-style panic as in most movies of this type, but there is some meeting of the minds and meeting of the neighbors, a herd of deer.

There’s more made of a quest of the youngest (Farrah MacKenzie) to find the final episode of “Friends” streaming somewhere than a quest to answer what the hell is happening, and the most prominent theory, from a survivalist neighbor played by Kevin Bacon, is about as close as we get to an explanation – until the final shot.

“Leave the World Behind” is a prime example of the type of apocalyptic story that focuses on the point of view of the everyman-and-woman rather than “Deep Impact”-style deliberations by POTUS deep in the White House bunker. I like a good presidential speech summing up the disaster and urging people to remain calm as anybody, but this is a good change.

‘Monarch: Legacy of Monsters’ is the Godzilla story I was waiting for

I should make this clear up front: I’ve never been the biggest fan of Godzilla movies.

I know that sounds like sacrilege coming from a lifelong monster movie fan. But while I can appreciate on-screen destruction and bellowing creatures as much as anyone, the Godzilla movies left me a little cold. Even the best of them, from the 1954 original with its nightmarish echoes of the atomic war waged on Japan, seemed to have a chasm between the huge creatures, called kaiju, and the people who had to contend with them.

I liked random moments in the many movie versions, including the 1980s reboot of the series and some of the 2010s films produced with bigger budgets. Frankly, the most enjoyable of them might be “Kong: Skull Island,” the 2014 film that worked to establish a shared universe between King Kong and Godzilla and the other giant creatures. The plan led to “Godzilla vs. Kong” in 2021.

But my leeriness about that divide between kaiju and people caused me to delay watching “Monarch: Legacy of Monsters,” airing on AppleTV+ starting in November. There was a lot of appeal to the show, to be sure, mostly father and son actors Kurt and Wyatt Russell playing the same character, Lee Shaw, at two points in the storyline, decades apart. So it’s a little stunty. Who doesn’t like a good stunt?

But if you come for the premise of a shadowy organization tracking, fighting and manipulating kaiju – here referred to as “Titans” – over more than a half a century – you’ll enjoy not only charismatic performances by the Russells but also one of the most photogenic and sympathetic casts in recent years, including Anna Sawai, Kiersey Clemons, Ren Watabe and Anders Holm. Not to mention the wonderful Tamlyn Tomita, who we last saw recreating her 1980s “Karate Kid” role in “Cobra Kai.”

There’s a pretty good amount of special effects spectacle in “Monarch” but it never gets repetitive. It punctuates the storyline with the appropriate level of terror mere humans would feel when confronted with literally dozens of Titans.

“Monarch” is carried by the intrigue of its plot, as Sawai and Watabe try to find the father they didn’t know they shared and turn to the elder Russell for help.

“Monarch” is set to run for 10 episodes through mid-January, so you have time to catch up. It’s fun and intriguing.

Death crowns and graveyards: my fascination with death and what follows

I have to admit I’m fascinated by death – which is probably understandable for a writer of true crime and crime fiction – but I’m especially fascinated by everything that follows death.

The picture above – forgive me for its “shot through glass” quality – is of a death crown, or angel crown. I’m writing a piece for CrimeReads about these bizarre artifacts of death, so I’ll save most of my explanation of death crowns for that, but I can tell that death crowns are a wreath, basically made of feathers from a feather pillow.

Folklore, especially Appalachian folklore, tells us that death crowns were found in the feather pillows of people who had recently died. I’ll tell you more in that upcoming CrimeReads article.

I’m not sure where my interest, even fascination, with death and funerals and cemeteries began. It probably had something to do with being exposed to so many funerals of extended family members when I was young. Complete with open caskets. It probably also had to do with the macabre stories and movies that I grew up on. I’ve written about that previously for CrimeReads.

Without quite realizing it, I’ve turned this interest in death into fodder for my fiction writing. I’ve written short stories about cemeteries and my crime novel “Seven Angels” is about a small town in Tennessee that was literally built around the graves of early 1800s settlers. The graveyard that is central to the story is based on my dad’s family graveyard down here in Tennessee. My main character is a woman who returns to the town of Seven Angels to help run her family’s funeral home and ends up as county coroner. The book won the Mystery Writers of America Hugh Holton Award for Best Unpublished Novel and I’m going to be working to get it out there in front of people in 2024.

I’m not sure I’ll ever get over my fascination with death and what follows, and I’m not sure I want to. It’s been more than a fascination for me. It’s been an inspiration.

The most famous woman journalist you never heard of: Elsie Robinson

Every so often, a book comes along and, besides being entertaining and educational, reminds us that so much has gone on in the past century – tumultuous events, colossal changes and incredible personalities – that our brains can’t keep track of it.

But you’d think that history would have kept better track of a newspaper reporter and writer whose work entertained and helped millions of readers because, after all, the newspaper industry is all about ensuring that its personalities and advances are well known and continue to be.

That’s not the case with Elsie Robinson, however, the subject of “Listen, World!” a biography by Allison Gilbert and my friend Julia Scheeres, the latter the author of two books I’ve long admired, “Jesus Land,” my fellow Indiana native’s recounting of her years rebelling against evangelical punishment of juveniles, and “A Thousand Lives,” an affecting reconstruction of the end of the cult of Rev. Jim Jones through the eyes of the people that followed him to Guyana.

For “Listen, World!” Scheeres and Gilbert have done the world and the history of journalism a great favor in telling the life of Robinson, who in the late 1880s and well into the mid-1900s, became a writer who was almost unparalleled in her time or any other: Robinson grew from humble beginnings to become one of the most highly paid newspaper writers and columnists of the time. Her platform in the newspapers of William Randolph Hearst (think “Citizen Kane”) brought her work to millions of readers every day.

Robinson was a blazer of trails and opinion maker although, as the authors note, she is largely forgotten now. I think most of us who worked in the newspaper industry know that fame isn’t the reason you get into the business – it wasn’t for Elsie, who had a lifelong unquenchable desire to write – but that someone read by millions every day could be overlooked within a half-century of her death is startling.

“Listen, World!” does an admirable job of remedying that.

It’s a hopeful time to be a Marvel fan

Momentum is a thing. Honestly, I think it’s even more of a thing than franchise fatigue.

Remember back in 2016, before Twitter went to hell and took a little bit of our democracy with it, when the biggest thing online that spring was whether you were Team Iron Man or Team Captain America?

It was a silly twitter hashtag stunt, of course, intended to drum up publicity for “Captain America: Civil War,” which came out that summer, introduced Black Panther and Spider-Man to the Marvel Cinematic Universe and helped build momentum for the final Avengers films in 2018 and 2019.

Momentum, all but wasted over the next couple of years by Covid-delayed MCU movies and Disney+ series that seemed too little, too late.

And I liked a lot of them. I was one of the people who really liked “The Marvels” a couple of weeks ago.

Now Marvel and Disney’s momentum is lost, thanks to assholish behavior by the studios that led to actors’ and writers’ strikes that, ultimately, proved only how greedy the studios and streaming services were.

So where do Marvel movie fans like me go from here?

I’ll certainly be seeing the third “Deadpool” movie when it comes out in July 2024. It’s the only “real” Marvel movie coming out during the year.

But then … 2025 and (barring more schedule shuffling) “Captain America: Brave New World,” featuring the starring debut of Anthony Mackie as Sam Wilson, the new Cap, then “Fantastic Four” and “Thunderbolts” and “Blade.”

I’m so excited to see how “Fantastic Four” shakes out because the FF were my favorites, along with the Avengers, when I was a comic-reading kid.

But I’m probably most hyped to see Mackie continue wearing the shield he won in the “Falcon and the Winter Soldier” series.

There’s a moment in the first “Iron Man” movie when Rhodey (then played by Terrence Howard) looks at Tony’s spare suit and says, “Next time, baby,” and the crowd in the theater with me fairly screamed at the possibility of the larger Marvel universe finding its way on screen – a possibility that seemed to be a real thing when Samuel L. Jackson showed up in the end credits,

I was ready then. I’m ready now. For more Marvel.

Sure ‘Die Hard’ is a Christmas movie, but what’s a Thanksgiving movie?

A few years ago, everybody got into the mock argument that “Die Hard” was a Christmas movie.

At least I think it was a mock argument. Y’all know that “Die Hard” really is a Christmas movie, right?

So I just saw something that made me wonder, what’s the best Thanksgiving movie?

So I found a Harper’s Bazaar article about the 60 greatest Thanksgiving films.

Are there really 60 Thanksgiving movies?

I have to say the list started in a manner that didn’t give me much confidence. in first place was “A Charlie Brown Thanksgiving,” which, yeah, of course, Thanksgiving, absolutely, sure, but … it’s 25 minutes long. Is it a movie? No, it’s really a long-ago TV special, and one I’m still fond of.

Looking down the rest of the list, there were a LOT of movies I’ve never heard of. I’m not gonna call them out here, but apparently Thanksgiving movies are not huge hits.

“You’ve Got Mail,” okay, fine, heard of it. “Alice’s Restaurant” is possibly the most inspired choice on the list. “Addams Family Values” stumped me for a minute, but yes, now I see it. “Planes, Trains and Automobiles” is a given.

“North by Northwest?”

I kept hoping there would be some startlingly inappropriate choice, but most were just … fine, okay, I’ll take your word for it.

Probably my favorite choice, that I didn’t remember had anything to do with “Thanksgiving” at all, “Knives Out,” the 2019 crime film classic.

But none of these, with the exception of the “Charlie Brown” short, will get you in the mood for Thanksgiving dinner.

And then only for popcorn, toast and jellybeans.

Slim Whitman and the curse of old daytime TV ads

Here’s one for all you young people out there, because I know the young people like Slim Whitman.

WTF, you might be asking, as the kids say “What the fuck?” nowadays.

Well, I was prompted to write about the classic singer of classic cowboy songs after watching a few minutes of daytime cable TV this morning.

I don’t watch a lot of cable TV. I’m more likely to watch something streaming. And I never really watch much cable during the day. But I was channel surfing this morning, trying without luck to find something to occupy my brain for a few minutes before I submitted a horror novella for consideration, when I observed how awful the basic cable commercials are.

Lots of prescription medicine, over the counter medicine, snakeoil medicine, etc. Some gadgety things that involve shedding more light on your driveway or making it easier to hear the TV. I don’t know about you, but the last thing I ever have any trouble hearing is the commercials in TV.

So I thought back to the misspent days of my misspent youth and the times I watched local TV channels and I swear to god it seemed like nearly every other commercial back was for record albums.

You might know them as vinyl.

Most of the commercials were for record collections: Hits of the 60s or earlier, great country songs, Boxcar Willie, Fats Domino and Slim Whitman.

For those of you who don’t know: Slim Whitman, pictured here, was a country singer who was known for his falsetto and his yodel. His bio says he opened for Elvis Presley at one point. His greatest claim to fame in the last quarter of the 20th century came when his song “Indian Love Call” caused the invading Martians’ brains to explode in the Tim Burton sci-fi spoof “Mars Attacks!” which was itself loosely based on a vintage set of bubblegum cards.

Whitman, who died at age 90 in 2013, was a bigger star in the United Kingdom than in the United States.

So there you go, young people. Aren’t you glad you asked?

The word of the day is inspiration

Inspiration.

I think it’s easy for writers to get hung up on some, well, inspirational idea of inspiration.

I’ve always been a believer that inspiration can be quick and easy, even down and dirty. I take inspiration all the time from what I see out in the world, what I read and hear.

Today on twitter, a fellow writer, Regan MacArthur, talked about how he would change the 1997 crime drama “Cop Land” to add a little more drama for the central character, a New Jersey sheriff played by Sylvester Stallone. You should go read Regan’s tweet and follow him because he’s always just as smart as you would expect him to be from that tweet.

What Regan’s done is take a pretty great story and tweaked it just a little bit and, in my opinion, made it better. In the process, he might have inspired himself or any number of other people to write a thematically similar but different story about hero worship and how that plays into fraught relationships.

I’m trying to use this blog to talk more about writing, so I’ll note that I’ve taken inspiration lately from Larkin Poe, a truly great pair of musician sisters (pictured here) who are excelling in their mix of rock, blues and country,

They inspired me to write a short story that I’ve submitted for possible inclusion in a big 2024 anthology. No matter how good I think my story might be – I like it pretty well – it probably won’t make that anthology because so many truly inspired writers have submitted stories for consideration. I’ll shop it around somewhere else because I like the story and wrote it in a little lightning strike of inspiration.

I’ve got another story rattling around in the back of my head – and in notes – that was inspired by a former neighbor who was such a nutcase that I decided there had to be something hinky about him.

So we’ll see how that inspiration goes.

In the meantime, think about what inspires you. It doesn’t have to be a bolt from Mount Olympus. It can be as little as a good movie, a mediocre story, a billboard, anything.

Just roll with that inspiration.